Chibasa wrote:Fuiji (math error) and Gara get BP for last round, Desu must had a BP 11/3 for math error which was forgotten. Don't really know how I'm supposed to deal with errors caught way too late (the error was caught late, but BP was not assigned). I guess updating BP (account & date) is the minimum, giving also the 6 round ban would be the maximum, and giving only one round ban would be approximately fair (punishment for 2BP) since we're near most important matches (end of period), so it's my choice.
Looking back at 3/11, was it the error caught at the time by this post
? If so, the BP not assigned by Chibasa/Momo at the time was most likely because Desufire is a mod and his edits are not recorded. I don't think it's fair to give him special treatment just because he has advantages as a mod or because it's closer to the important matches. It was caught at the time, and he did fix it so he was aware of it (even though he didn't bring it up again after the fact). The rules are there for a reason, are they not?
Since it's a late punishment, I suggest that in this case a more "fair" thing to do would be to give him the 6 match ban on the same day in the next period. That way, he still gets the same weight of punishment the rest of us would get, and it affects the impact on Necklace at the same time as if the punishment had been at the time of offence. It's a different necklace so the stakes may be different, but it doesn't seem fair that he can get away with a reduced ban just because he's a mod and he can get away with editing posts without other people realizing. Everyone else gets penalized the same, so I don't see why he should get special treatment.
0 Kinomoto Sakura - Ikkyuu Tensai 0
1 Shiina - Tedeza Rize 0
0 Hachikuji Mayoi - Fleurenza Latifa 1
2 Sento Isuzu - Haqua Du Lot Herminium 1
2 Yuuki Mikan - Sonoda Umi 0
0 Kiryuu Nagisa - Zen 0
Ikkyuu Tensai > Kinomoto Sakura - disable
Tedeza Rize > Shiina
Fleurenza Latifa > Hachikuji Mayoi - confirm
Sento Isuzu > Haqua Du Lot Herminium - reverse
Yuuki Mikan > Sonoda Umi - confirm
Kiryuu Nagisa > Zen
Kinomoto Sakura > Ikkyuu Tensai
Tedeza Rize > Shiina
Fleurenza Latifa > Hachikuji Mayoi
Haqua Du Lot Herminium > Sento Isuzu
Yuuki Mikan > Sonoda Umi
Zen > Kiryuu Nagisa