Your ISML list...

[Corni]

THIS IS PLACE TO PUT YOUR ISML LIST...

KS NOTE: If you are stuck making your list:

Although, for anyone else who wants to make a full list of 64 girls, this applet would probably help in roughly sorting them all. It works by a method where you do a series of comparisons between two girls, whether girl A > girl B or vice versa, and by transitive properties, if A > B and B > C then A > C etc etc etc ...

My 2nd version after using CCY applet:-

1.Yuuhi Katagiri
2.Hinagiku Katsura
2.Kagami Hiiragi
2.Fate Testarossa
5.Kirino Chiba
6.Alice Carroll
7.Patchouli Knowledge
8.Ayu Tsukimiya
9.Suiseiseki
10.Hanyuu
11.Illyasviel von Einzbern
12.C.C.
13.Sayuri Kurata
13.Hayate Yagami
15.Aya Shameimaru
16.Yami [Golden Darkness]
17.Ayumu "Osaka" Kasuga
18.Mikoto Misaka
19.Kotomi Ichinose
20.Anya Alstreim
21.Mei Sunohara
22.Rin Tohsaka
23.Shiori Misaka
24.Marisa Kirisame
25.Minori Kushieda
26.Taiga Aisaka
27.Yuki Nagato
27.Shana
27.Horo
30.Misuzu Kamio
30.Rena Ryuuguu
30.Mai Kawasumi
33.Nagi Sanzenin
34.Rika Furude
34.Index
34.Shinku
37.Saber
37.Nagi
39.Tamaki Kawazoe
39.Maria
39.Nayuki Minase
39.Tsukasa Hiiragi
39.Haruhi Suzumiya
39.Mikuru Asahina
39.Sugintou
39.Amu Hinamori
39.Reimu Hakurei
48.Ami Kawashima
49.Akari Mizunashi
49.Makoto Sawatari
49.Shiki Ryogi
49.Konata Izumi
49.Evangeline A.K. McDowell
54.Sakura Kinomoto
54.Chii
54.Nagisa Furukawa
54.Tomoyo Sakagami
54.Nanoha Takamachi
54.Vita
60.Remilia Scarlet
61.Kyou Fujiyabashi
61.Kallen Kouzuki
63.Louise Valliere
64.Fuuko Ibuki

So Hayate that high huh... and lol at number 2... Fate/Hinagiku/Kagami

[Seishi]

Copying my post from the Top 10 Moe thread

Top-Tier: Will always vote against a lower tier no matter what. Not in any set order (besides Nanoha) yet within the tier.

Nanoha Takamachi
Reimu Hakurei
Aya Shameimaru
Taiga Aisaka
Sakura Kinomoto
Rika Furude
Hinagiku Katsura
Shinku
Nagi (Kannagi)
Louise Valliere

2nd Tier: Still good moe. Also not in any particular order.

Mikoto Misaka
Shiori Misaka
Haruhi Suzumiya
Fate T. Harlaown
Misuzu Kamio
Ayu Tsukimiya
Hanyuu
Nagi Sanzenin
Rena Ryuuguu
Marisa Kirisame
Amu Hinamori
Kagami Hiiragi
Evangeline A.K. McDowell
Kirino Chiba
Tamaki Kawazoe
Hayate Yagami

EDIT: More lists...

3rd Tier: Still moe, but usually only on a good day. In no particular order.

Rin Tohsaka
Makoto Sawatari
Akari Mizunashi
Alice Carroll
Nayuki Minase
Remilia Scarlet
Index
Konjiki no Yami
Mei Sunohara
Kyou Fujibayashi
Nagisa Furukawa
Suiseiseki
Vita
Minori Kushieda
Ami Kawashima

4th Tier: Mostly indifference bordering on dislike for some. Usually these characters can only go up from here.

Illyasviel von Einzbern
Konata Izumi
Yuki Nagato
C.C.
Shiki Ryougi
Maria
Patchouli Knowledge
Mai Kawasumi
Sayuri Kurata
Yuuhi Katagiri
Ayumu "Osaka" Kasuga
Tomoyo Sakagami
Kotomi Ichinose
Horo

5th Tier: These characters will probably never receive votes from me unless they go against each other and I feel up to voting for one on that day. This does not mean I dislike all these characters.

Mikuru Asahina
Saber
Kallen Statdfeld
Suigintou
Tsukasa Hiiragi
Anya
Chii

Wow, I'm really nice this year. I was predicting my 5th tier to be at least double that. Might as well give some characters a good shot.

[chaosprophet]

The only ones I have well defined are my top 5 (my Hall of Moe Fame Group):

1) Evangeline McDowell
2) Kushieda Minori
3) Fate Testarossa
4) Nagato Yuki
5) Chiba Kirino

From there on it's divided in groups kinda like Seishi ones. Each group has the character in a order of preference it easily changes depending of my mood at the time. So the order inside each group may vary (even more if two characters are not many positions apart from each other) but a character from a higher group would always recieve a vote against one from a lower group (even if it's the last of a group against the first of the group directly below).

Top Moe Group - usually have one, or two in rare cases, character of the series I love the most

Louise (ZnT)
Nagi (HnG)
Yami (Tlr)
Konata (LS)
Tosaka (Fsn)
Shana (SnS)
Ilya (Fsn)
Osaka (AD)
Horo (SaW)
Taiga(TD)
Ami (TD)
Mikoto (TAMnI)

Very Moe Group - those that gave me a strong moe impression but not as much as the ones of the above group
Saber (Fsn)
Tamaki (BB)
Kagami (LS)
Sakura (CCS)
Shinku (RM)
Index (TAMnI)
Nagi (Kannagi)
Suigintou (RM)

Moe Group - tthe ones tha gave me a moe impression but not a really strong one

Hinagiku (HnG)
Hayate (MSLN)
Haruhi (SHnY)
Nanoha (MSLN)
Vita (MSLN)
Suiseiseki (RM)
Maria (HnG)
Tsukasa (LS)
Yuuhi (AinSnS)
Remilia (Touhou)
Reimu (Touhou)

Not Moe / Indifferent group - the ones that didn't gave me a moe impression at all

Marisa (Touhou)
Patchouli (Touhou)
Aya (Touhou)
Mikuru(SHnY)



The remaining 24 characters are from series I haven't watched yet.

[LazyCanuck]

eh lets see

1/2 Fate/Nanoha
3 Shana
4 Horo

that's really the only 4 i ever care about when it comes to Moe the rest really do depend entirely on my mood so i cant really put them in any particular order.

I can put them into Teirs for the most part though, Note these are NOT in any order its all random

High Tier-I find them really moe
Yami-chan
Hinagiku
Kotomi
(only three lol..i almost could put them into the group above in spots 5, 6 and 7 but whatever)


Middle tier- they hit the moe spot just not enough to be really noteable for myself
Nayuki
Reimu
Ayu
Sayuri
Mai
Rika
Hanyuu
Illya
Tomoyo
Kyou
Nagi
Rena
Saber
Makoto
Mei
Aya
Remilia
Misuzu

Low-ish tier-its not so much that don't find these girls moe it just didn't hit me that much at all, not sure why
Taiga
Kirino
Marisa
Nagisa
Fuuko
Index
Yuuhi
Tamaki
Maria
Mikoto
Shiori
Mikuru

Extra- Girls that i dont really have much of an opinion on, either they showed no moe or not enough of my kind of moe.
Haruhi
Shinku
Gin
Desu
Ami
Minori
Rin
Hayate
Vita
Patchouli

Just plain not moe what so ever.
Yuki
CC (have not seen anime going by pictures and general opinion from others)
Konata (same as above)
Kallen (same as CC)


The rest- I have not seen their animes at all and pictures and word of mouth is all i can go by
The Aria girls-Looking at their pictures they do look rather Cute so they may get some votes from based on that alone.
The Code Geass girls-Frankly i don't like the look of any of them, they all look funny so no votes from me at all.
Chii-i have not seen Chobits, and i have not looked into it much at all, so no opinion on her, wont be getting votes though.
Evangeline-Have not seen Negima, pictures are meh, same thing as Chii pretty much.
Kagami Hiiragi-Have not seen LS, but i hear good things about her anyway, i don't like the design of the LS girls though, no votes from me.
Amu Hinamori-Dont know her at all but looking at her character design and pictures and etc she looks pretty cute, she might get a few votes based on that
Osaka-Dont know her at all, looking at her picture doesnt give off much, probably no votes.
Sakura Kinomoto-i have never seen CCS at all, and for some odd reason nothing about her pictures shout out MOE~ to me, She may or may not get votes, it all depends on a few things I guess.
Louise-I have not seen ZnT, and I've seen a fair number of pictures, votes for her will depend entirely on who shes facing.
Shiki- I'm waiting until all 7 KnK movies are done before i touch this, looking at pictures i dont get any moe vibes, so probably no votes from me.



OK i think thats all of them, like i said before dont take this as solid measurements of how i look at moe, since my opinion changes a fair bit depending on the day and my mood and who faces who and etc.~

[Seishi]

Sakura Kinomoto-i have never seen CCS at all, and for some odd reason nothing about her pictures shout out MOE~ to me, She may or may not get votes, it all depends on a few things I guess.

[Demi.]

Omg, I'm so lazy I don't even know how I convinced myself into doing this...

Let's see~

Fate Testarossa
Takamachi Nanoha
Konjiki no Yami
Yagami Hayate
Alice Caroll
Kinomoto Sakura
Furude Rika
Katsura Hinagiku
Ichinose Kotomi
Ryūgū Rena
Suigintou
Chii
Illyasviel von Einzbern
Vita
Evangeline McDowell
Furude Hanyū
Suiseiseki
Tōsaka Rin
Kawazoe Tamaki
Shinku
Nagi
Shana
Tsukimiya Ayu
Holo
Mizunashi Akari
Kamio Misuzu
Suzumiya Haruhi
Asahina Mikuru
Sunohara Mei
Nagato Yuki
Maria
Kawashima Ami
Chiba Kirino
Kawasumi Mai
Misaka Mikoto
Aisaka Taiga
Kushieda Minori
Minase Nayuki
Sanzen'in Nagi
Louise Vallière
Misaka Shiori
Hinamori Amu
Hiiragi Kagami
Sawatari Makoto
Fujibayashi Kyō
Hiiragi Tsukasa
Index
Furukawa Nagisa
Ibuki Fūko
Sakagami Tomoyo
Saber
Anya Alstreim
C.C.
Kurata Sayuri
Katagiri Yūhi
Kōzuki Kallen
Ryōgi Shiki
Kasuga ''Ōsaka'' Ayumu
Izumi Konata

____
Touhou girls go here cause I'm just not sure what to do with them just yet.
Hakurei Reimu
Kirisame Marisa
Patchouli Knowledge
Remilia Scarlet
Shameimaru Aya

Atleast Kholdstare still has me trumped in MGLN fanboiness.

Long story short, I love cute, sweet, kind, adorable characters, and I dislike (most) bitches. I'll leave it for you to decide what character archtype possess the most bitches.

Also, I don't recall Sakura being quite so high on your moe list last year Seishi. High she was, but not THAT high.

[Chocola]

Okay I'll divide this into tiers:

My Top 7 "will never vote against" this year:
1) Sakura Kinomoto
2) Hinagiku Katsura
3) Nagisa Furukawa
4) Nanoha Takamachi
5) Kagami Hiiragi
6) Vita
7) Fate Testarossa

Very moe, I love:
8) Hanyuu Furude
9) Amu Hinamori
10) Shiori Misaka
11) Tsukasa Hiiragi
12) Mikoto Misaka
13) Misuzu Kamio
14) Shana
15) Mei Sunohara
16) Louise Vallière
17) Nagi Sanzenin
18) Ayu Tsukimiya
19) Index
20) Minori Kushieda
21) Reimu Hakurei

Moe, but not exceptional:
22) Tomoyo Sakagami
23) Rika Furude
24) Haruhi Suzumiya
25) Taiga Aisaka
26) Makoto Sawatari
27) Suiseiseki
28) Yuki Nagato
29) Marisa Kirisame
30) Hayate Yagami
31) Nagi [Kannagi]
32) Rena Ryuuguu
33) Fuuko Ibuki
34) Konata Izumi

Whatever:
35) Illyasviel von Einzbern
36) Kyou Fujibayashi
37) Mikuru Asahina
38) Chii
39) Shinku
40) Horo
41) Ami Kawashima
42) Patchouli Knowledge
43) Golden Darkness
44) Sayuri Kurata
45) Aya Shameimaru
46) Maria
47) Mai Kawasumi
48) Remilia Scarlet
49) Yuuhi Katagiri
50) Nayuki Minase
51) Kotomi Ichinose
52) Alice Carroll

Don't care for:
53) C.C.
54) Kasuga "Osaka" Ayumu
55) Anya Earlstreim
56) Suigintou
57) Akari Mizunashi
58) Kirino Chiba
59) Kallen Kouzuki
60) Saber
61) Shiki Ryougi
62) Tamaki Kawazoe [BB]
63) Rin Tosaka
64) Evangeline McDowell

[Seishi]

Demi: She was 3rd all year.

[Demi.]

Demi: She was 3rd all year.

So there was only two times you voted against her? Somehow, I'm remembering a slightly different story, lol. That's not to say It's a bad thing, just not what I remember. But alas, I think you might just know more than me on this subject...perhaps.

[Kaito_Dash]

My Top 5: (Will always have my votes every match)
1 Fate Testarossa Harlaown
2 Takamachi Nanoha
3 Hinamori Amu
4 Sakagami Tomoyo
5 Katsura Hinagiku

My Beloved: (Will also gets my votes if they don't go against my top ones)
6 Nagato Yuki
7 Furukawa Nagisa
8 Fujibayashi Kyou
9 Misaka Mikoto
10 Kinomoto Sakura
11 Kirisame Marisa
12 Hakurei Reimu
13 Yagami Hayate
14 Asahina Mikuru
15 Kawazoe Tamaki
16 Katagiri Yuuhi
17 Ichinose Kotomi
18 Konjiki no Yami
19 Maria
20 Vita
21 Kouzuki Kallen
22 Syameimaru Aya

Considerably Moe:
23 Tohsaka Rin
24 Kurata Sayuri
25 Anya Alstreim
26 Misaka Shiori
27 Sunohara Mei
28 Mizunashi Akari
29 Minase Nayuki
30 Kawasumi Mai
31 Tsukimiya Ayu

Moe but not to me: (May have some votes from me if I'm in good mood)
32 Shana
33 Suzumiya Haruhi
34 Hiiragi Tsukasa
35 Chiba Kirino
36 Alice Carroll
37 Hiiragi Kagami
38 Saber
39 Ibuki Fuuko
40 Kamio Misuzu
41 Sawatari Makoto
42 Chi
43 Sanzenin Nagi
44 C.C.
45 Horo
46 Suigintou
47 Evangeline A.K. McDowell
48 Illyasviel von Einzbern
49 Aisaka Taiga

Don't really mind:
50 Kushieda Minori
51 Index
52 Kawashima Ami
53 Ryougi Shiki
54 Remilia Scarlet
55 Patchouli Knowledge
56 Izumi Konata
57 Nagi
58 Louise Françoise le Blanc de la Vallière

Whatever:
59 Ryuguu Rena
60 Furude Rika
61 Furude Hanyuu
62 Shinku
63 Kasuga 'Osaka' Ayumu
64 Suiseiseki

[NeZZuri]

My Top 5

Takamachi Nanoha
Shana
Yuki Nagato
Fate Testarossa
Konata

I'll just vote for these 5 contestants , if they go against each other I'll vote from the top to bottom. Others I'll have a look or depends

[Demi.]

My Top 5: (Will always have my votes every match)
1 Fate Testarossa Harlaown
2 Takamachi Nanoha
3 Hinamori Amu
4 Sakagami Tomoyo
5 Katsura Hinagiku

I remember this top 5 from somewhere...lol -
MAL user?

Edit: Just saw your siggy...Strange, because I don't recall that MAL name.

[Seishi]

Nice lists...I approve of NeZZ's avatar.

*uppercuts Demi*

[Mushi]

I hate making lists.

Sakura Kinomoto-i have never seen CCS at all, and for some odd reason nothing about her pictures shout out MOE~ to me...

At least try to give it the full 8 minutes.

SpoilerShow

She hits me with moe the minute she wakes up.

[Demi.]

Nice lists...I approve of NeZZ's avatar.

*uppercuts Demi*

Oh now you've done it...

Because of that, the secrets out - You forgot to list Shana, and one other character I have failed to find.

And yeah, Sakura is a Mahou Shoujo you would have to be pretty freakin dense to hate. She's kinda Nano-ish, except not quite so combative.

I'll just vote for these 5 contestants , if they go against each other I'll vote from the top to bottom. Others I'll have a look or depends

Make sure to vote for three others as well, 'cause 8 is the minimum you can vote for and still have your vote accepted.

[Blacksmith_Tony]

Well here's my list, the highlighted ones are the girls I don't really know.

These are the characters that I'm always going to vote for, and I'll be sad when they face each other:

SpoilerShow

Illyasviel von Einzbern
Shana
Kamio Misuzu
Takamachi Nanoha
Katagiri Yūhi
Sawatari Makoto
Ryūgū Rena
Aisaka Taiga
Furude Rika

I'll vote for this group as much as I can, but certainly not above the 1st group:

SpoilerShow

Suiseiseki
Index
Fate Testarossa
Yagami Hayate
Tōsaka Rin - Probably my favourite character in ISML, but she's not the most moe.
Minase Nayuki
Hinamori Amu
Kurata Sayuri
Nagi
Holo
Furukawa Nagisa
Tsukimiya Ayu
Misaka Shiori
Ichinose Kotomi
Furude Hanyū
Kushieda Minori
Kawasumi Mai
Shinku
Fujibayashi Kyō
Vita
Katsura Hinagiku

These are the pretty "meh" characters, either characters I've not seen much of or those that I have that didn't really do anything for me:

SpoilerShow

Kinomoto Sakura
Kawashima Ami
Sanzen'in Nagi
Sunohara Mei
Chii
Kasuga ''Ōsaka'' Ayumu
Maria
Mizunashi Akari
Konjiki no Yami
Alice Carroll
Hakurei Reimu
Hiiragi Kagami
Izumi Konata
Asahina Mikuru
Louise Vallière
Saber
Misaka Mikoto
Suzumiya Haruhi
Ibuki Fūko

I'll only vote for these if they're against each other, although in some cases I'd rather abstain:

SpoilerShow

Patchouli Knowledge
Remilia Scarlet
Kawazoe Tamaki
Kirisame Marisa
Shameimaru Aya
Chiba Kirino
Hiiragi Tsukasa
Sakagami Tomoyo
Suigintou
Evangeline McDowell
Ryōgi Shiki
Nagato Yuki
Anya Alstreim
C.C.
Kōzuki Kallen

[Chiharu]

I only have a top 10 right now, but later I may make a full list. xD

1. Rika Furude
2. Sakura Kinomoto
3. Marisa Kirisame
4. Taiga Aisaka
5. Misuzu Kamio
6. Remilia Scarlet
7. Ayu Tsukimiya
8. Makoto Sawatari
9. Fate Testarossa
10. Hanyuu Furude

[ithekro]

I don't think I'll set up a full top twenty list again.
However there are two constents:
1. I will never vote against Nagato Yuki.
2. Everyone else will be "taken home" by Rena Ryugu.

[Chocola]

Wow thanks guys. I already flamed LazyCanuck on #isml for hating on Sakura, but I'm glad many of you share the same feelings as I as well.

[Cecaniah]

-sighes at so much C.C. and Anya dislike-

Most people won't vote for them here...

C.C. is my top priority, Anya coming second, then the rest I don't care for.

Question. Would anyone care if Kallen went through this tournament with 0 wins, and 63 losses?