Page 1 of 1

Shinka-chan! Unlock Your Heart! (CD 1308)

Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2014 3:54 am
by ISML Seitokai
We will force Crisu to change the necklace formula to a better one that is more reflective of period performance. Some of us are sick at the staff doing lazy math with random numbers. Also, fire maglor! Long Live Queen Hikarin!

Council Directive 1308

Introduced by: Nibutani Shinka
Proposal: The necklace formula will be changed to: SDO + 220 * Vote%
Consent: Nibutani Shinka, Takanashi Touka
Dissent: none
Abstain: Kuroyukihime, Takanashi Rikka, Dekomori Sanae

Comments:

Shinka: We now move on to this paper from office of numerical research. It seems that the current formula for the ISML necklace was not optimal, as it did not give balanced weight to both factors present. According to their words, in most occasions, one of the factors simply didn't matter. Therefore it is suggested that a change to (SDO + c * Vote%) would restore balance, where 215 < c < 224. The factor should be... :onion50:

Dekomori: I see an opening! *tackles Shinka*

Shinka: Ow!! :onion19: :onion23:

Dekomori: Huhuhu! Your evil plan to subvert the Seitokai into a minion of the institute will never succeed... :onion52:

Shinka: What evil plan? I am merely suggesting- :onion8:

Dekomori: *squirts* :onion10: Behold the power of our newest technology, the Superdimensional Wave Gun!

Shinka: Why... you... little... BRAT! :onion38: *throws a tomato at Deko-chan*

Dekomori: :onion79: You shall not use my master's kryptonite to harm me!
_____
Image
Nibutani Shinka
Secretary
ISML Seitokai
Image

Re: Shinka-chan! Unlock Your Heart! (CD 1308)

Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2014 4:27 am
by maglor
By the way, part of tomato got on Takanashi Touka, so she promptly used the ladle on Shinka and Dekomori. Someone post the picture of Shinka and Dekomori both having bumps on their head.

Re: Shinka-chan! Unlock Your Heart! (CD 1308)

Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2014 4:29 am
by blaZofgold
So...did it actually change? Cool.

And I wonder who wrote this.

Re: Shinka-chan! Unlock Your Heart! (CD 1308)

Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2014 4:41 am
by LOveLive!
More difficult to overcome SDO disadvantage than before? :roll:

Re: Shinka-chan! Unlock Your Heart! (CD 1308)

Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2014 5:51 am
by maglor
LOveLive! wrote:More difficult to overcome SDO disadvantage than before? :roll:
Please check the entire 17 necklace period record. You will see that necklace group match result is the most dominant factor in determining the OVERALL necklace finish rank. I urge you to check the Speareman's Correlation value between necklace finish, necklace group match result, and SDO. ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spearman%2 ... oefficient" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false; ) I tried many statistical testing, and with the data at hand, there was greater chance that SDO was NOT enough to overcome necklace group match result compared to necklace group match result not being enough to overcome SDO disadvantage. Please also consider that the reason why SDO seems to play a bigger role, even though statistical testing clearly says it does not, is merely because you get to see SDO first. Also, I checked the correlation between SDO and necklace group match result and they turned out to be lower than correlation between final necklace finish rank and necklace group match result. There exist too many cases where those with very low SDO ended up with very high necklace group match result to suggest that SDO is determining factor for the necklace group match.

Check the discussions at viewtopic.php?f=30&t=4506&start=20#p245792" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

Also check the following graphs for relationship between SDO and necklace group round result. The R^2 value is below 0.3, which means rather weak correlation. The correlation between necklace group round results and eventual necklace finish rank is much higher.

-------------------------

In order to save you the trouble of doing the calculations yourself, here is the Spearman's rank correlation coefficient for the 2012-2013 formula

Between SDO rank and Necklace Finish rank : 0.663509409
Between Necklace Group round result rank and Necklace Finish rank : 0.808823529
Between SDO rank and Necklace Group Round Result Rank : 0.346499358


The reason why we need to discuss the rank, and not who ended up being 1st : The simple reason is, there just isn't sufficient number of cases for this to give meaningful result. We will be using only 17 datapoint for this calculation. By including what happens at 2nd to 7th, we are increasing number of relevant datapoint by 7 fold, thus 119 datapoint. With 100+ datapoint, you can have some confidence in your analysis. With only 17, the uncertainty is too great, and what seems to be a pattern usually turns out to be mere coincidences.

Re: Shinka-chan! Unlock Your Heart! (CD 1308)

Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2014 6:24 am
by Shmion84
I didn't realize that this rule was already changed two days ago.
Article XVIII.E wrote:[16 April 2014] The Necklace Score calculation was updated for the 2014 Regular Season.
Article XII.G wrote:At the end of the round, each Contestant receives a Necklace Score, calculated as the sum of her SDO for the entire Period and her voting percentage for the round multiplied by 220. (SDO + 220*Vote%)
Let's hope for even more interesting Necklace Matches.

Re: Shinka-chan! Unlock Your Heart! (CD 1308)

Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2014 6:41 am
by 10ZHAbin
Such a serious matter feels more appropriate to be handed out by Kuroyukihime, is she still asleep?

Re: Shinka-chan! Unlock Your Heart! (CD 1308)

Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2014 6:48 am
by Chocola
10ZHAbin wrote:Such a serious matter feels more appropriate to be handed out by Kuroyukihime, is she still asleep?
Unfortunately the only serious one in this ragtag Seitokai is Shinka. You can definitely blame maglor for this.

Re: Shinka-chan! Unlock Your Heart! (CD 1308)

Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2014 6:57 am
by kanohistorm
maglor wrote:By the way, part of tomato got on Takanashi Touka, so she promptly used the ladle on Shinka and Dekomori. Someone post the picture of Shinka and Dekomori both having bumps on their head.
No...but I always have a rolled up newspaper as substitute
Image

Re: Shinka-chan! Unlock Your Heart! (CD 1308)

Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2014 7:21 am
by blaZofgold
^ What anime is that from?

Re: Shinka-chan! Unlock Your Heart! (CD 1308)

Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2014 7:34 am
by shiraoky
blaZofgold wrote:^ What anime is that from?
Kono Naka ni Hitori Imouto ga Iru (NakaImo)

Re: Shinka-chan! Unlock Your Heart! (CD 1308)

Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2014 8:29 am
by kanohistorm
shiraoky wrote:
blaZofgold wrote:^ What anime is that from?
Kono Naka ni Hitori Imouto ga Iru (NakaImo)
Don't watch it

Re: Shinka-chan! Unlock Your Heart! (CD 1308)

Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2014 9:08 am
by JLoable91
kanohistorm wrote:
shiraoky wrote:
blaZofgold wrote:^ What anime is that from?
Kono Naka ni Hitori Imouto ga Iru (NakaImo)
Don't watch it

Re: Shinka-chan! Unlock Your Heart! (CD 1308)

Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2014 10:33 am
by Fuijiwara
why?

Re: Shinka-chan! Unlock Your Heart! (CD 1308)

Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2014 12:47 pm
by Chocola
Fuijiwara wrote:why?
I haven't watched it, but I'm going to try a few guesses:

1) it sucks
2) annoying clingy imouto
3) generic romance harem with bad plot
4) absolutely no development from any girl
5) just a big boob fest

or all of the above?

Re: Shinka-chan! Unlock Your Heart! (CD 1308)

Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2014 1:54 pm
by JLoable91
KholdStare88 wrote:
Fuijiwara wrote:why?
I haven't watched it, but I'm going to try a few guesses:

1) it sucks
2) annoying clingy imouto
3) generic romance harem with bad plot
4) absolutely no development from any girl
5) just a big boob fest

or all of the above?
Yeah, all of the above
+ 2) 5 annoying clingy 'imoutos'
6) dat dumb male protagonist

Re: Shinka-chan! Unlock Your Heart! (CD 1308)

Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2014 3:18 pm
by kanohistorm
JLoable91 wrote:
KholdStare88 wrote:
Fuijiwara wrote:why?
I haven't watched it, but I'm going to try a few guesses:

1) it sucks
2) annoying clingy imouto
3) generic romance harem with bad plot
4) absolutely no development from any girl
5) just a big boob fest

or all of the above?
Yeah, all of the above
+ 2) 5 annoying clingy 'imoutos'
6) dat dumb male protagonist
Yeah, pretty much.
I personally liked some of the characters (rinka-tan <3), but it's one of those shows where I just don't recommended watching.

Re: Shinka-chan! Unlock Your Heart! (CD 1308)

Posted: Sat Apr 19, 2014 4:53 am
by kukimunstir
Fireeeee Himeee

Not really sure about the system and stuff but yea hopefully we get to see interesting results

Re: Shinka-chan! Unlock Your Heart! (CD 1308)

Posted: Sat Apr 19, 2014 10:46 am
by Fuijiwara
kanohistorm wrote:
JLoable91 wrote:
KholdStare88 wrote:
Fuijiwara wrote:why?
I haven't watched it, but I'm going to try a few guesses:

1) it sucks
2) annoying clingy imouto
3) generic romance harem with bad plot
4) absolutely no development from any girl
5) just a big boob fest

or all of the above?
Yeah, all of the above
+ 2) 5 annoying clingy 'imoutos'
6) dat dumb male protagonist
Yeah, pretty much.
I personally liked some of the characters (rinka-tan <3), but it's one of those shows where I just don't recommended watching.

Bascially generic harem anime?

Re: Shinka-chan! Unlock Your Heart! (CD 1308)

Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2014 3:02 am
by superunature
kanohistorm wrote:
JLoable91 wrote:
KholdStare88 wrote:
Fuijiwara wrote:why?
I haven't watched it, but I'm going to try a few guesses:

1) it sucks
2) annoying clingy imouto
3) generic romance harem with bad plot
4) absolutely no development from any girl
5) just a big boob fest

or all of the above?
Yeah, all of the above
+ 2) 5 annoying clingy 'imoutos'
6) dat dumb male protagonist
Yeah, pretty much.
I personally liked some of the characters (rinka-tan <3), but it's one of those shows where I just don't recommended watching.


HAS CUTE GIRLS, NOTHING ELSE MATTERS. K THX BAI~