Page 3 of 4

Re: ISML 2017 Fall Seasonal Tournament - General Discussion

Posted: Wed Nov 08, 2017 8:27 pm
by Veon
Barely managed to collect 8 girls... and find 3 series to nominate.

Minowa Gin @ Yūki Yūna wa Yūsha de Aru
Nogi Sonoko @ Yūki Yūna wa Yūsha de Aru
Yuuki Yuuna @ Yūki Yūna wa Yūsha de Aru
Kunikida Hanamaru @ Love Live! Sunshine!!
Kurosawa Ruby @ Love Live! Sunshine!!
Sakuranomiya Maika @ Blend S
Hinata Kaho @ Blend S
Hoshikawa Mafuyu @ Blend S

And this is a season when I watched more than usual...
Keima wrote: Since I posted a thread about someone I thought should be considered the "Best Girl of All Time", at first my nomination sheet was going to look like this:
SpoilerShow
Image
Perfect ballot. Wish I could do this.

Re: ISML 2017 Fall Seasonal Tournament - General Discussion

Posted: Thu Nov 09, 2017 10:44 am
by maglor
Toady wrote:Ayase Yue is my favorite Negima character. Is she eligible? (I don't watch UQ Holder, so I wouldn't know.)
I'm afraid Ayase Yue did not make sufficient appearance, nor plot contribution, yet. Therefore, she isn't eligible.

Re: ISML 2017 Fall Seasonal Tournament - General Discussion

Posted: Thu Nov 09, 2017 10:50 am
by maglor
niwa87 wrote:
HasbeenaHibiki wrote:
Reverend wrote:If only Lily is eligible.... :(
I know right :frown:
Wait, Lily not eligible? Is it because of rule number 8? Now my list down one more character... :(
Basically, it is because of rule number 8. The essence of a being may be who possesses the mind. Unlike Tanya Degurechaff who can never go back to being male, Lily mere virtual avatar of a male character. If we didn't know Lily's owner, I would say Lily probably was the most moe feminine character of the season, but we clearly know the owner. Thus, we need to make a special tournament for a character like Lily.

Re: ISML 2017 Fall Seasonal Tournament - General Discussion

Posted: Fri Nov 10, 2017 11:33 am
by Fuijiwara
Image

Re: ISML 2017 Fall Seasonal Tournament - General Discussion

Posted: Fri Nov 10, 2017 12:19 pm
by maglor
renfire wrote:Diamond @ Hōseki no Kuni
Hoshikawa Mafuyu @ Blend S
Amano Miu @ Blend S
Aida Miou @ Itsudatte Bokura no Koi wa 10cm datta
Shirakawa Miyako @ Imōto sae Ireba Ii.
Yūki Yūna @ Yūki Yūna wa Yūsha de Aru
Komiya Ena @ Just Because!
Chito @ Shōjo Shūmatsu Ryokō
Yūki Yūna @ Yūki Yūna wa Yūsha de Aru <- Yuuna did not appear in this season yet, therefore she isn't eligible. Please sitemail us a replacement pick.

Re: ISML 2017 Fall Seasonal Tournament - General Discussion

Posted: Fri Nov 10, 2017 12:30 pm
by maglor
kurogaga wrote:Hatori Chise @ Mahoutsukai no Yome
Morioka Moriko @ Net-juu no Susume
Sakuranomiya Maika @ Blend S
Aida Miou @ Itsudatte Bokura no Koi wa 10cm datta
Natsume Mio @ Just Because!
Yuuri @ Shoujo Shuumatsu Ryokou
Chito @ Shoujo Shuumatsu Ryokou
Lykos @ Kujira no Kora wa Sajou ni Utau
Aida Miou @ Itsudatte Bokura no Koi wa 10cm datta <- This did not air yet, so not eligible for now. Please sitemail us a replacement pick

Re: ISML 2017 Fall Seasonal Tournament - General Discussion

Posted: Fri Nov 10, 2017 12:57 pm
by exec
  • Aoyama Erika @ Animegataris
  • Tachibana Sylphinford @ Himouto! Umaru-chan
  • Ebina Nana @ Himouto! Umaru-chan
  • Peach Maki @ Hoozuki no Reitetsu
  • Izanami @ Hoozuki no Reitetsu
  • Evangeline Athanasia Katherine McDowell @ UQ Holder!
  • Ayase Yue @ UQ Holder!
  • Yukihiro Ayaka @ UQ Holder!
It's hard to pick anything when all you have is this...
Image

Re: ISML 2017 Fall Seasonal Tournament - General Discussion

Posted: Fri Nov 10, 2017 2:14 pm
by maglor
exec wrote:
  • Aoyama Erika @ Animegataris
  • Tachibana Sylphinford @ Himouto! Umaru-chan
  • Ebina Nana @ Himouto! Umaru-chan
  • Peach Maki @ Hoozuki no Reitetsu
  • Izanami @ Hoozuki no Reitetsu
  • Evangeline Athanasia Katherine McDowell @ UQ Holder!
  • Ayase Yue @ UQ Holder!
  • Yukihiro Ayaka @ UQ Holder!
It's hard to pick anything when all you have is this...
Image
Sorry but Ayase and Yukihiro didn't appear enough, yet. Please send RegalStar and I your replacement picks via sitemail

Re: ISML 2017 Fall Seasonal Tournament - General Discussion

Posted: Fri Nov 10, 2017 2:15 pm
by maglor
Mizusawa Chisato @ Osake wa Fuufu ni Natte kara
Hatori Chise @Mahoutsukai no Yome
Shimada Mayu @ Wake Up, Girls!
Nogi Sonoko @ Yūki Yūna wa Yūsha de Aru
Phosphophyllite @ Hōseki no Kuni
Evangeline Athanasia Katherine McDowell @ Negima Series
Chito @ Shōjo Shūmatsu Ryokō
Yūri @ Shōjo Shūmatsu Ryokō

Re: ISML 2017 Fall Seasonal Tournament - General Discussion

Posted: Fri Nov 10, 2017 2:40 pm
by exec
maglor wrote:Sorry but Ayase and Yukihiro didn't appear enough, yet. Please send RegalStar and I your replacement picks via sitemail
Last season I had the same concern with Hachikuji Mayoi and Regal said she was fine since she hadn't been in the tournament for long enough time.
Now I nom-nom charas from negima, and suddenly they are not eligible since not enough cameo in the current series.

Re: ISML 2017 Fall Seasonal Tournament - General Discussion

Posted: Sat Nov 11, 2017 3:10 am
by Karob
Sakuranomiya, Maika @ Blend S
Komiya, Ena @ Just Because!
Morikawa, Hazuki @ Just Because!
Natsume, Mio @ Just Because!
Hatori, Chise @ Mahōtsukai no Yome
Morioka, Moriko @ Net-jū no Susume
Chito @ Shoujo Shuumatsu Ryokou
McDowell, Evangeline Athanasia Katherine @ Negima Series

And my heart votes for Lily (Net-juu) and Kuromaru (UQ Holder / Negima Series), who aren't decidedly female.

Re: ISML 2017 Fall Seasonal Tournament - General Discussion

Posted: Sat Nov 11, 2017 9:05 pm
by niwa87
Image
1. Gamer Rize...
2. Blanc, is it you?
3. Unintended sadistic moe.
4. Naru and Chisame successor.
5. Really nice girl. I find her much more moe than Umaru since first season.
6. For the lol. Well, her look and fake persona is quite moe. Plus Horie Yui. Her real self? -_-
7&8. For Reverend. Already briefly run through the anime. The atmosphere remind me of Gakkou Gurashi. The girls look okay so far.
ineligible...Show
1. Lily - Netjuu no Susume
maglor wrote:...I would say Lily probably was the most moe feminine character of the season...
^This. Too bad she is not eligible...
2. Miyazaki Nodoka, Izumi Ako, Sasaki Makie, Kuu Fei, Ayase Yue and other Negima's casts - UQ Holder
Just a cameo in this Negima 'sequel'. As for Nodoka and Yue, not yet relevant at this point of anime...
3. Tokisaka Kuroumaru - UQ Holder
Genderless, for now...

Re: ISML 2017 Fall Seasonal Tournament - General Discussion

Posted: Sat Nov 11, 2017 10:36 pm
by Reverend
niwa87 wrote: 7&8. For Reverend. Already briefly run through the anime. The atmosphere remind me of Gakkou Gurashi. The girls look okay so far.
Thank you, pyuru!
*hugs*

You should watch it properly once you have time. It's one of those anime you need to pay attention and think if you want to get the meat.
(well, but a lot of people are already content just with the iyashikei moe sol skin, so it's not like you have to put much effort if you don't want to.)

Gakkou Gurashi, huh?
Not many people compare it to that (well, not many people even remember about it, sadly) but I can see why would someone compare the two.
I miss that anime. Maybe I should redownload and watch it again.

Re: ISML 2017 Fall Seasonal Tournament - General Discussion

Posted: Sun Nov 12, 2017 12:12 am
by Kordosa

Re: ISML 2017 Fall Seasonal Tournament - General Discussion

Posted: Sun Nov 12, 2017 12:39 am
by XIQQ
maglor wrote:
renfire wrote:Diamond @ Hōseki no Kuni
Hoshikawa Mafuyu @ Blend S
Amano Miu @ Blend S
Aida Miou @ Itsudatte Bokura no Koi wa 10cm datta
Shirakawa Miyako @ Imōto sae Ireba Ii.
Yūki Yūna @ Yūki Yūna wa Yūsha de Aru
Komiya Ena @ Just Because!
Chito @ Shōjo Shūmatsu Ryokō
Yūki Yūna @ Yūki Yūna wa Yūsha de Aru <- Yuuna did not appear in this season yet, therefore she isn't eligible. Please sitemail us a replacement pick.
She appeared in episode 6, aired yesterday and before the end of the nomination period, so she should be eligible.

Re: ISML 2017 Fall Seasonal Tournament - General Discussion

Posted: Sun Nov 12, 2017 5:28 am
by maglor
XIQQ wrote:
maglor wrote:
renfire wrote:Diamond @ Hōseki no Kuni
Hoshikawa Mafuyu @ Blend S
Amano Miu @ Blend S
Aida Miou @ Itsudatte Bokura no Koi wa 10cm datta
Shirakawa Miyako @ Imōto sae Ireba Ii.
Yūki Yūna @ Yūki Yūna wa Yūsha de Aru
Komiya Ena @ Just Because!
Chito @ Shōjo Shūmatsu Ryokō
Yūki Yūna @ Yūki Yūna wa Yūsha de Aru <- Yuuna did not appear in this season yet, therefore she isn't eligible. Please sitemail us a replacement pick.
She appeared in episode 6, aired yesterday and before the end of the nomination period, so she should be eligible.
If she had more than 3 spoken lines, or had some contribution to the plot with her appearance, she is eligible. If that was mere passing shot, without any spoken line, nor plot contribution, she still isn't eligible. Please tell me which is the correct case, as I didn't have time to check episode 6 yet.

Re: ISML 2017 Fall Seasonal Tournament - General Discussion

Posted: Sun Nov 12, 2017 6:12 am
by XIQQ
maglor wrote:
XIQQ wrote:
maglor wrote:
renfire wrote:Diamond @ Hōseki no Kuni
Hoshikawa Mafuyu @ Blend S
Amano Miu @ Blend S
Aida Miou @ Itsudatte Bokura no Koi wa 10cm datta
Shirakawa Miyako @ Imōto sae Ireba Ii.
Yūki Yūna @ Yūki Yūna wa Yūsha de Aru
Komiya Ena @ Just Because!
Chito @ Shōjo Shūmatsu Ryokō
Yūki Yūna @ Yūki Yūna wa Yūsha de Aru <- Yuuna did not appear in this season yet, therefore she isn't eligible. Please sitemail us a replacement pick.
She appeared in episode 6, aired yesterday and before the end of the nomination period, so she should be eligible.
If she had more than 3 spoken lines, or had some contribution to the plot with her appearance, she is eligible. If that was mere passing shot, without any spoken line, nor plot contribution, she still isn't eligible. Please tell me which is the correct case, as I didn't have time to check episode 6 yet.
She had 4 spoken lines in episode 6.

Re: ISML 2017 Fall Seasonal Tournament - General Discussion

Posted: Sun Nov 12, 2017 6:43 am
by XIQQ
I'm thinking that the nomination rules have to be refined, especially for the Fall seasonal tournaments.

For one, it's unclear as to how movies should be treated. Should it be by its BD release date, or its theatrical release date? For the latter, what countries should be considered?
If a character first appeared as a female in Winter season, but is revealed to be a male in Spring season, is that character eligible?
Also, I think there should be an exact time period applied for the Fall tournament, rather than just "Fall". Sometimes we know a new major character is going to appear in advance (via the cast list, original manga/lightnovel, PV, next episode preview, etc.), so people might put down characters that have yet to appear.

By the way, I've nominated Kongou Hikari, from Himouto! Umaru-chan, but now I'm not sure if she's eligible. She hasn't appeared in person yet, but she had 3 lines in episode 3, as the CV for an in-anime game's character. She's listed on the anime's official website's character list as well, so it's certain that she will appear in person within the season.

Re: ISML 2017 Fall Seasonal Tournament - General Discussion

Posted: Sun Nov 12, 2017 7:56 am
by maglor
XIQQ wrote:I'm thinking that the nomination rules have to be refined, especially for the Fall seasonal tournaments.

For one, it's unclear as to how movies should be treated. Should it be by its BD release date, or its theatrical release date? For the latter, what countries should be considered?
If a character first appeared as a female in Winter season, but is revealed to be a male in Spring season, is that character eligible?
Also, I think there should be an exact time period applied for the Fall tournament, rather than just "Fall". Sometimes we know a new major character is going to appear in advance (via the cast list, original manga/lightnovel, PV, next episode preview, etc.), so people might put down characters that have yet to appear.

By the way, I've nominated Kongou Hikari, from Himouto! Umaru-chan, but now I'm not sure if she's eligible. She hasn't appeared in person yet, but she had 3 lines in episode 3, as the CV for an in-anime game's character. She's listed on the anime's official website's character list as well, so it's certain that she will appear in person within the season.
1. Yuuki Yuuna and Kongou Hikari are eligible. When we are not sure about the plot contribution, we go by number of spoken line. If it is 3 or more, we give the character benefit of doubt.

2. Movie is treated by how much legit multi-continental sale it garnered. If we can be reasonably sure tens of thousands of people saw the movie in multiple continents, we consider it to have received sufficient international exposure, thus consider it eligible for the seasonal. If only people in Japan saw the movie, then we don't consider it to be sufficient exposure, thus go by BD release date.

3. If a character appeared as a female, and there was no way regular anime watchers with no knowledge of spoilers can know the character actually is a male, then we are forced to consider the character to be eligible for the seasonal, since we said we go by the character data. When the character is revealed as male in a broadcasted episode, we would start considering the character as male, and the character loses any right it had to the female division.

4. There is an exact time period applied for Fall Tournament. The cutoff for the data to be considered is the same time Nomination closes.

Re: ISML 2017 Fall Seasonal Tournament - General Discussion

Posted: Tue Nov 14, 2017 4:31 am
by Fuijiwara
QualifiedShow
Asagaya Minoa @ Anime-Gataris
Sakuranomiya Maika @ Blend S
Hinata Kaho @ Blend S
Kōsaka Akiho @ Boku no Kanojo ga Majime Sugiru Shōjo Bitch na Ken
Cardia Beckford @ Code:Realize - Sōsei no Himegimi
Marie @ Dies Irae
Gina @ Garo the Animation
Motoba Kirie @ Himōto! Umaru-chan
Ebina Nana @ Himōto! Umaru-chan
Diamond @ Hōseki no Kuni
Phosphophyllite @ Hōseki no Kuni
Kani Nayuta @ Imōto sae Ireba Ii.
Shirakawa Miyako @ Imōto sae Ireba Ii.
Niwa Ryōka @ Jūni Taisen
Natsume Mio @ Just Beacause!
Komiya Ena @ Just Beacause!
Chain Sumeragi @ Kekkai Sensen
Kino @ Kino no Tabi
Yuzu @ Konohana Kitan
Sami @ Kujira no Kora wa Sajō ni Utau
Lykos @ Kujira no Kora wa Sajō ni Utau
Takami Chika @ Love Live! Sunshine!!
Hatori Chise @ Mahōtsukai no Yome
Evangeline McDowell @ Negima Series
Morioka Moriko @ Net-jū no Susume
Schwi Dola @ No Game No Life
Mizusawa Chisato @ Osake wa Fūfu ni Natte kara
Honda Chiemi @ Ōsama Game The Animation
Chito @ Shōjo Shūmatsu Ryokō
Yuuri @ Shōjo Shūmatsu Ryokō
Kobayashi Rindō @ Shokugeki no Sōma
Miyata Yuri @ Two Car
Watatasumugi Kotoko @ URAHARA
Shimada Mayu @ Wake Up, Girls!
Tōgō Mimori (Washio Sumi) @ Yūki Yūna wa Yūsha de Aru
Nogi Sonoko @ Yūki Yūna wa Yūsha de Aru