ISML 2018 Summer Seasonals Discussion

[D1amodpizi]

Platelet Leader (Hataraku Saibō)
Rachel Gardner (Angels of Death)
Hoshimi Junna (Shōjo ☆ Kageki Revue Starlight)
Oono Akira (High Score Girl)
Yukimura Aoi (Yama no Susume)
Rinne Ohara (ISLAND)
Rem Galleu (How NOT to Summon a Demon Lord)
Shera·L·Greenwood (How NOT to Summon a Demon Lord)
Voter Id: 247c968d-52e1-5982-a669-91362fd02e36

[HasbeenaHibiki]

Honda Hanako (Asobi Asobase)
Olivia (Asobi Asobase)
Red Blood Cell (AE3803) (Hataraku Saibou)
Mitsukuri Sasame (Ongaku Shojo)
Yukino Hiyo (Ongaku Shojo)
Kunikida Ayumu (Free)
Matsuzaka Satou (Happy Sugar Life)
Nomura Kasumi (Asobi Asobase)

[tehyc]

[Corni]

Honda Hanako (Asobi Asobase)
Tsuyuzaki Mahiru (Shoujo ☆ Kageki Revue Starlight)
Jashin-chan (Jashin-chan Dropkick)
Sakura Futaba (Persona 5)
Hanesaki Ayano (Hanebado!)
Rem Galeu (Isekai Maou to Shoukan Shoujo no Dorei Majutsu)
Miyazaki Chisaki (Yuragi-sou no Yuuna-san)
Kuga Asahi (Shichisei no Subaru)

Voter Id: 96fb0f53-3ae8-510b-9a25-fe0c2a40e17d

[houreki]

[kurogaga]

Platelet (Leader) (Hataraku Saibō)
Kotegawa Chisa (Grand Blue)
Honda Hanako (Asobi Asobase)
Hanesaki Ayano (Hanebado!)
Oono Akira (High Score Girl)
Kuroi Ginko (Planet With)
Miyamo Chio (Chio-chan no Tsūgakuro)
Rachel Gardner (Satsuriku no Tenshi)


Voter Id: 59707a19-1f0e-5fdb-b27c-69cce1f1151b

[lycheecoffee]

Red Blood Cell (AE3803) (Hataraku Saibou)
Platelet Leader (Hataraku Saibou)
Rinne Ohara (ISLAND)
Ohara Rinne (ISLAND)
Aijou Karen (Shōjo ☆ Kageki Revue Starlight)
Ryouko Naoe (Sirius the Jaeger)
Rachel Gardner (Satsuriku no Tenshi (Angels of Death))
Voter Id: e567396d-721e-5478-965e-aff1eaee1b2c

[Kiwigiwi]

Your Nominations were successfully submitted
Rachel Gardner (Satsuriku no Tenshi)
Daiba Nana (Shoujo Kageki Revue Starlight)
Kagura Hikari (Shoujo Kageki Revue Starlight)
Mashiro Amatsuki (One Room)
Historia Reiss (Shingeki no Kyojin)
Platelet leader (Hataraku Saibou)
Voter Id: 06f93072-6e10-56fd-8357-d2dfd90e7bf8

[WoodyMC]

Rachel Gardner (Satsuriku no Tenshi)
Daiba Nana (Shoujo Kageki Revue Starlight)
Hoshimi Junna (Shoujo Kageki Revue Starlight)
Mashiro Amatsuki (One Room)
Matsuzaka Satou (Happy Sugar Life)
Koube Shio (Happy Sugar Life)
Abiko Yu (Muhyo to Rouji no Mahouritsu Soudan Jimusho)
Shiratoya Nae (Inazuma Eleven: Ares no Tenbin)
Voter Id: 0a74ee8c-df1f-5a3c-8846-3c32a19e755c

Pretty sure I'm the only one that nominate #7 and #8 but whatev~

[starryrainynight]

奥莉薇亚 (来玩游戏吧)
本田华子 (来玩游戏吧)
野村香纯 (来玩游戏吧)
松坂砂糖 (Happy Sugar Life)
神户盐 (Happy Sugar Life)
五月七日茴香 (中二病也要谈恋爱)
七宫智音 (中二病也要谈恋爱)
凸守早苗 (中二病也要谈恋爱)
Voter Id: 87263f61-a050-5f33-a7be-3eccfea896f1

[niwa87]

Before I end up wasting one nomination slot, I want to ask for clarification. Could I nominate a character from Gundam Build Diver? Even though the series starts during spring season, none of their characters pass the nomination stage for spring tournament. Doesn't that means the series did not participate in previous seasonal tournament?

[maglor]

Before I end up wasting one nomination slot, I want to ask for clarification. Could I nominate a character from Gundam Build Diver? Even though the series starts during spring season, none of their characters pass the nomination stage for spring tournament. Doesn't that means the series did not participate in previous seasonal tournament?

In the past, if none of the characters pass the nomination stage for the season right before it, we accepted it as same as not having participated in the previous seasonal tournament. Unless someone can post why we should change the precedent in the case you are interested in, your nomination of a character from Gundam Build Diver should count.

[xxx]

湯之花幽奈 (搖曳莊的幽奈小姐)
宮崎千紗希 (搖曳莊的幽奈小姐)
真城葵 (京都寺町三條商店街的福爾摩斯)
雪拉·L·古林伍德 (異世界魔王與召喚少女的奴隸魔術)
蕾姆·嘉蕾鄔 (異世界魔王與召喚少女的奴隸魔術)
七橋御乃梨 (One Room)
花柳香子 (少女☆歌劇 Revue Starlight)
西條克洛迪娜 (少女☆歌劇 Revue Starlight)
Voter Id: aac7b9a1-236f-5c53-8fdc-03a058506ce8

[IGNITE]

Overlord was eligible for Winter 2018 due to season 2, so only characters appearing after 30th of June should be eligible.

You are right

Nase Mitsuki (2015 Autumn Winner)
Eligible for 2015 summer through kako-hen

Kushina Anna (2015 Autumn candidate)
Eligible for 2015 spring though K:missing King

Kagura (2018 winter)
eligible for 2017 winter through Gintama(2017). and autumn through poriri-hen

Uraraka Ochako (2018 spring winner)
eligible for 2017 spring - summer though academia 2nd season

Overlord doesn't really have any female character for seasonal, but rules gotta be consistent at least within a year.

[maglor]

Overlord was eligible for Winter 2018 due to season 2, so only characters appearing after 30th of June should be eligible.

You are right

Nase Mitsuki (2015 Autumn Winner)
Eligible for 2015 summer through kako-hen

Kushina Anna (2015 Autumn candidate)
Eligible for 2015 spring though K:missing King

Kagura (2018 winter)
eligible for 2017 winter through Gintama(2017). and autumn through poriri-hen

Uraraka Ochako (2018 spring winner)
eligible for 2017 spring - summer though academia 2nd season

Overlord doesn't really have any female character for seasonal, but rules gotta be consistent at least within a year.

In all the cases you mentioned, none of the series you mentioned had a character that passed the nomination stage in the season you mentioned. Therefore it didn't violate the rule " The character's anime series appeared within the the previous four Seasonal Tournaments* " . In case of Ochako, no one from Hero Academia was among the 36 that qualified for 2017 Summer Seasonal Tournament. Therefore, Hero Academia was considered to not having appeared for the tournament, thus she was eligible for 2018 Spring seasonal.

[IGNITE]

In all the cases you mentioned, none of the series you mentioned had a character that passed the nomination stage in the season you mentioned. Therefore it didn't violate the rule " The character's anime series appeared within the the previous four Seasonal Tournaments* " . In case of Ochako, no one from Hero Academia was among the 36 that qualified for 2017 Summer Seasonal Tournament. Therefore, Hero Academia was considered to not having appeared for the tournament, thus she was eligible for 2018 Spring seasonal.

So I guess being eligible means "passed the nomination" rather than "eligible for the nomination"?

Charter IV: C. 3.Show

The character was not eligible for any of the previous four (4) Seasonal Tournaments.

[maglor]

In all the cases you mentioned, none of the series you mentioned had a character that passed the nomination stage in the season you mentioned. Therefore it didn't violate the rule " The character's anime series appeared within the the previous four Seasonal Tournaments* " . In case of Ochako, no one from Hero Academia was among the 36 that qualified for 2017 Summer Seasonal Tournament. Therefore, Hero Academia was considered to not having appeared for the tournament, thus she was eligible for 2018 Spring seasonal.

So I guess being eligible means "passed the nomination" rather than "eligible for the nomination"?

Charter IV: C. 3.Show

The character was not eligible for any of the previous four (4) Seasonal Tournaments.

More like we miswrote the rule. The trouble with using "eligible for" is that it is much harder to check compared to "passed the nomination". One of the contributing reasons to why no one from Hero Academia qualified for 2017 Summer Seasonal is that almost everybody thought they were ineligible because they were definitely not eligible during season right before it. When we have these kind of situation, it may beget the question that "is it fair to make a character ineligible because she actually was eligible in a seasonal where everyone thought she was ineligible?" So, we are discussing how to best reword the rule to properly state the "passed" condition instead of "eligible for". You can check the current draft of the new rule in the following thread : viewtopic.php?f=35&t=8722

[Summer Pockets]

Hanasaka Yui (One Room)
Nanahashi Minori (One Room)
Amatsuki Mashiro (One Room)
Red Blood Cell (AE3803) (Hataraku Saibō)
Platelet Leader (Hataraku Saibō)
Ohara Rinne (ISLAND)
Kurutsu Karen (ISLAND)

Voter Id: b84f9698-346e-539f-87ba-d1ae396b74f1

[Karob]

Sylvie (Isekai Maō to Shōkan Shōjo no Dorei Majutsu)
Miyamo, Chio (Chio-chan no Tsūgakuro)
Nonomura, Manana (Chio-chan no Tsūgakuro)
Sekkekkyuu AE3803 (Red Blood Cell) (Hataraku Saibō)
Kuroi, Ginko (Planet With)
Kotegawa, Chisa (Grand Blue)
Kotegawa, Nanaka (Grand Blue)
Yoshiwara, Aina (Grand Blue)

Voter Id: ebb0825e-40cc-531b-af73-ee86ed4e80ab

[niwa87]

In the past, if none of the characters pass the nomination stage for the season right before it, we accepted it as same as not having participated in the previous seasonal tournament. Unless someone can post why we should change the precedent in the case you are interested in, your nomination of a character from Gundam Build Diver should count.

Noted. Thanks for the clarification.

My nomination :

Your Nominations were successfully submitted
Sarah (Gundam Build Diver)
Medusa (Jashin-chan Dropkick)
Poporon (Jashin-chan Dropkick)
Sylvie (Isekai Maou to Shoukan Shoujo no Dorei Majutsu)
Edelgard (Isekai Maou to Shoukan Shoujo no Dorei Majutsu)
Linnea (Hyakuren no Haou to Seiyaki no Valkyria)
Usui Satsuki (Shichisei no Subaru)
Kurutsu Karen (Island)
Voter Id: aec06aae-e127-585a-ac7c-f7e69f1ca44e

out of quotaShow

Jashin, Yurine from Jashin dropkick
Rem, Shera, Krum from Isekai Mao
Christina from Hyakuren
Asahi from Subaru
Rinne, Sara from Island
Chisaki from Yuuragi Yuna

It feel weird nominating the same character for two consecutive season, but I think Sarah really deserve the slot, especially after the second part of Gundam Build Diver. The consequences, Chisaki end up missed the last slot. (If it is Hibari, I might have a harder time to leave her out of slot though).