Divine Circlet/Crown Poster Results

Discussions about the exhibition period, including the seasonal tournament, goes here.
Post Reply
User avatar
Chibasa
[You can (not) Zura]
[You can (not) Zura]
Posts: 2660
Joined: Fri Oct 02, 2015 1:52 pm
Badges:
ImageImage
Worships: Yamada Naoko
Melon Pan: 120
2018 Female Favorite: Nishimiya Shōko
2018 Male Favorite: Kyon
2017 Female Favorite: Kasumigaoka Utaha
2017 Male Favorite: Okazaki Tomoya
Wish: Creating the best card game
Location: France

Divine Circlet/Crown Poster Results

Post by Chibasa » Tue Jan 08, 2019 12:23 pm

Welcome to the Divine Circlet & Divine Crown Awards.

This year we had many posters to judge and here are the results ! Let's start with honorable mentions:
Akame Honorable MentionsShow
In 5th position of the Akame Poll, we have AK2. (WoodyMC)
Image
This poster managed to have a decent result in Tieba with 6 votes (tied 2nd) and had an overall rating of 4.07.

In 4th position we have AK7. (houreki)
Image
This poster was 2nd choice for our judges with a mean score of 7/10 and had an overall rating of 5.16.
Senjougahara Hitagi Honorable MentionsShow
In 5th position of the Hitagi Poll, we have SH6. (MiranFroaude)
Image
This poster managed to have a decent result in Tieba with 6 votes (3rd) and had an overall rating of 4.04.

In 4th position we have SH5. (houreki)
Image
This poster was 3rd choice for our judges with a mean score of 6,5/10 and got 4 votes in forum (2nd). It had an overall rating of 5.10.

Kiwi comment: Some issues with the render of Hitagi used, but otherwise, quite a pretty poster.
Izayoi Miku Honorable MentionsShow
In 5th position of the Miku Poll, we have IM5. (tongeyi)
Image
This poster had an overall rating of 4.10.

In 4th position we have IM3. (XxPurple-CrystalxX)
Image
This poster was 1st choice for our judges with a mean score of 7,5/10 and did a decent performance in forum with 3 votes (4th). It had an overall rating of 5.46.
Hyakuya Mikaela Honorable MentionsShow
In 4th position of the Mikaela Poll, we have HM6. (tongeyi)
Image
This poster had an overall rating of 4.00 barely making it to honorable mention thanks to his 5 votes in Tieba (3rd).

Time to reveal our third of each poll now !
Akame #3Show
AK1 is our 3rd ! (IGNITE)
Image
(1st tie) on forum with 4 votes, (2nd tie) on Tieba with 6 votes and 3rd on judges score with 6,2/10 made this poster deserve a final 6.77 score !
Senjougahara Hitagi #3Show
SH3 is our 3rd ! (kukimunstir)
Image
Correct performances on Tieba and forum, along with 2nd on judges score with 6,8/10 made this poster deserve a final 5.14 score !
Teruhashi Kokomi #3Show
TK3 is our 3rd ! (epeldoll)
Image
With a very weak opposition, this poster found its way towards podium. Being 3rd choice for the judges with a 4.1/10, it reaches 2.57 score.
Izayoi Miku #3Show
IM4 is our 3rd ! (wakamurasaki)
Image
(Tied 1st) on forum with 4 votes, (2nd) on Tieba with 10 votes and with a correct performance of 5.1/10 this poster got 7.18 final score ! Which is the best score of all 3rd !
Hyakuya Mikaela #3Show
HM5 is our 3rd ! (houreki)
Image
(2nd) on forum with 4 votes and 3rd place by judges with 6,2/10 made this poster deserve a final 5.97 score !
Tsunayoshi Sawada #3Show
ST4 is our 3rd ! (kukimunstir)
Image
Left alone on forum and Tieba, this poster got 1st place by judges with 6,1/10. Final score 3.62 !
All Might #3Show
AM1 is our 3rd ! (IGNITE)
Image
(Tied 2nd) on forum and 3rd on judge ranking with a 4.7/10, this poster got a final 5.37 score !

And now it's second turn !
Akame #2Show
AK6 from (kagome10)
Image
An extremely solid performance in Tieba (1st) with 14 votes and with a good follow-up on forum (3rd) with 3 votes made this poster almost win the Akame poll with a 7.17 final score !
Alphonse Elric #2Show
AE1 from (IGNITE)
Image
There were only 2 posters but both were pretty decent in the end. A close fight that this poster could have win thanks to Tieba support but 7 votes wasn't enough (1st). A score of 6.3/10 by judges which is almost the same as winner, AE1 lost battle on forum poll with only 2 votes (2nd).
Final score of 6.52.
Senjougahara Hitagi #2Show
SH2 from (epeldoll)
Image
Carried by his performance on Tieba, (1st) with 9 votes but moderately received by forum and judges with 2 votes and a 4.3/10. This poster reached a 5.47 final score.
Hyakuya Mikaela #2Show
HM7 from (MiranFroaude)
Image
A solid performance in Tieba (1st) with 11 votes along with a good follow-up by judges 2nd with 6.4/10. This poster lost the title on forum with only 2 votes but still reaches 6.76 final score !

Kholdy comment: Simplistic but poster-like, needs more contrast.
Izayoi Miku #2Show
IM1 from (IGNITE)
Image
A pretty decent performance in Tieba (3rd) with 8 votes, a shared (1st) place on forum with 4 votes and a 3rd rank by judges with 6.6/10 made this poster reach runner-up position in a competitive poll. Final score: 7.35.
Tsunayoshi Sawada #2Show
ST7 from (tongeyi)
Image
No particular performances to note anywhere but more consistency than all the ones behind. This poster got 4 votes in Tieba, 2 on forum and 4.4/10 by judges. Final score: 3.96.
Teruhashi Kokomi #2Show
TK2 from (WoodyMC)
Image
A (1st) place on forum with 5 votes, a decent (2nd) place on Tieba with 10 votes but a mediocre performance for judges with 3.5/10. Not enough for title and only 6.07 final score.
All Might #2Show
AM4 from (Aizawa)
Image
With a solid performance on forum (1st) with 5 votes and a 2nd place by judges with 5.7/10 this poster reaches 6.92 final score.

And the winners are...
Akame WinnerShow
AK4 from kukimunstir
Image
(1st tied) on forum with 4 votes and best performance of all posters for judges with 9/10. This poster got the title with 7.24 final score ! What a close match !

Kholdy comment: Nice poster pose, decent bg, decent amount of effects, can hide some of the stars.
Alphonse Elric #1Show
AE2 from (WoodyMC)
Image
Thanks to it 6 forum votes (1st) this poster won the title ! A solid performance of 6.4/10 by judges also helped to get 7.70 final score.

Chibasa comment: The alchemy between the colors and lighting is well done. It would be a good Sapphire poster !
Senjougahara Hitagi #1Show
SH1 from (IGNITE)
Image
With the strongest forum performance (1st) with 8 votes, a 1st rank by judges 8.4/10 and 8 votes on Tieba (2nd), this poster reach the best overall performance: 9.03 final score.

Kiwi comment: A very pretty poster. Good choice of background and picture. It really feels like you're going stargazing with Hitagi.
Hyakuya Mikaela #1Show
HM3 from (kukimunstir)
Image
A solid performance on forum (1st) with 5 votes along with a 1st place by judges with 8.8/10. This poster got title with a 8.70 final score !

Kiwi comment: Favourite poster overall. The background and sunflowers chosen to go with Mikaela is beautiful and gives off a very princely, peaceful vibe to him.
Izayoi Miku #1Show
IM6 from (MiranFroaude)
Image
One of the best performance on Tieba (1st) with 14 votes, a shared (1st) place on forum with 4 votes and 2nd rank by judges with 6.9/10 made this poster get the title with a solid 8.76 final score ! Second overall best performance.

Kiwi comment: Good pose, artist didn't go overboard with the effects which is good. That really large white sparkle in the middle isn't really necessary though.
Tsunayoshi Sawada #1Show
ST3 from (epeldoll)
Image
A very well acclaimed poster on Tieba and forum both (1st) with 12 and 5 votes respectively along with 3rd place by judges with a 5.8/10 gave this poster title and a final score: 8.32. This is the most outrageous victory of all polls.

Chibasa comment: I think this poster have very well intricate effects and good base picture choice, same for lighting.
Teruhashi Kokomi #1Show
TK4 from (wakamurasaki)
Image
With the best Tieba performance (1st) with 18 votes and an average 5/10 but still 1st place by judges, this poster got title and 8.32 as final score.
All Might #1Show
AM2 from (WoodyMC)
Image
A Tieba (1st) place and (1st) place by judges with 7.7/10 brung this poster towards title and a 8.48 final score !

Kiwi comment: Good choice of picture and lighting. The white dots don't really fit the picture, though.
ImageImage
Secret Santax Time
much more stuff than ToadyShow
Image
Image
ImageImageImageImageImage
Hikarin is the best
User avatar
Chibasa
[You can (not) Zura]
[You can (not) Zura]
Posts: 2660
Joined: Fri Oct 02, 2015 1:52 pm
Badges:
ImageImage
Worships: Yamada Naoko
Melon Pan: 120
2018 Female Favorite: Nishimiya Shōko
2018 Male Favorite: Kyon
2017 Female Favorite: Kasumigaoka Utaha
2017 Male Favorite: Okazaki Tomoya
Wish: Creating the best card game
Location: France

Re: Divine Circlet/Crown Poster Results

Post by Chibasa » Tue Jan 08, 2019 2:43 pm

Thanks to all participants !
ImageImage
Secret Santax Time
much more stuff than ToadyShow
Image
Image
ImageImageImageImageImage
Hikarin is the best
FestiveTony
Ninja
Ninja
Posts: 3
Joined: Fri Feb 08, 2019 10:33 am
Badges:
Melon Pan: 50
2018 Female Favorite: Aragaki Ayase
2017 Female Favorite: Aoyama Nanami

Re: Divine Circlet/Crown Poster Results

Post by FestiveTony » Mon Feb 18, 2019 3:04 pm

These were great entries, overall. :)
Post Reply