Well, SWVDO is surely fair for all Tier 2 and Wildcard compare to SDO. Much much more fair.maglor wrote:For the necklace, thank you for your comments and I want to inform you that we are looking at several alternatives which may better help Tier 2 or wildcardmatchbaby wrote:I think RPI is too difficult-_-
Why don't you make a SWVDO(Sum of defeated opponent weighted VP of one period)
As I think the idea for SDO is to reduce the effect of NM vote and give some benefits to strong 1v1er.
However, it is very unfair to Tier 2 or Wildcard.(Also, it depends on 'luck' ,and SDO of one period CAN'T show the strength of a character surely)
SWVDO can solve the above problem.
In extra, anti-vote will happen all way though the period if we use SWVDO instead of SDO, so more miracle can be seen.(As many people are complaining that Saimoe is boring as not many upset can be seen)
Also, for PSI's swiss system, I have something to say.
I think the rule should be changed as following:
1. most wisn in PSI.
2. if A and B have same wins, the winner of A vs B(if A haven't meet B in PSI,then include regular season) will be ahead.
3. if A and B and C have same wins and A>B, B>C, C>A, then, compare their strongest opponent.
4. regular season ranking.
For PSI, it would take very rare set of coincidence for your 4 line rule to have different result compared to current 3 line rule. I would appreciate it if you can give us some examples where your rule will have different outcome compared to current 3 line rule, so I may better understand what are the cases I forgot to consider.
For PSI, I use Nova as example.
Assume Asuna vs Kotori, Yoshino vs Kurumi on semi-final in PSI and Kurumi+Kotori wins.
As Asuna had faced KYH and Yoshino had faced Eru, for the final result, KYH is 3W1L and Eru is 2W2L, so Asuna will be ahead and grab the third spot, Yoshino will be demoted to forth. (As Kurumi lose in final, she must be second instead of forth or fifth)
However, Yoshino wins Asuna and KYH in Regular season and KYH wins Asuna in Regular Season, they are all 3W1L, but the "weakest" Asuna is ahead.
So third should be Yoshino(wins Asuna in Regular Season), forth is Asuna(wins KYH in PSI), fifth is KYH.
As same as 2W2L, I assume Eru, Tsu, Rikka, Tohka, Nanami, Shinka all 2W2L,
using the present rule, Eru(win Nanami and Tohka)>Tsu(win Nanami and Tohka)>Rikka(win KUROUSAGI, Shinka)
However, in Regular Season, Eru> Tsu> Rikka> Eru, which is A>B>C>A, so I think using the regular season's ranking(Rikka> Eru> Tsu) is better than now's (Eru>Tsu>Rikka)?