Game: ISML, The Different Story

[lischan]

INVALID

ResultsShow

0 Makise Kurisu - Kanbaru Suruga 3
0 Haqua Du Lot Herminium - Tedeza Rize 3
1 Yoshino - Rachel Alucard 1
0 Yuuki Mikan - Sakagami Tomoyo 4
0 Shiina - Ikkyuu Tensai 4
2 Koiwai Yotsuba - Alice Caroll 10

Kanbaru Suruga > Makise Kurisu
Tedeza Rize > Haqua Du Lot Herminium
Yoshino > Rachel Alucard (confirm)
Sakagami Tomoyo > Yuuki Mikan ( confirm)
Ikkyuu Tensai > Shiina - disable
Alice Caroll > Koiwai Yotsuba (reverse)

Match proposal:
Makise Kurisu > Kanbaru Suruga
Haqua Du Lot Herminium > Tedeza Rize
Rachel Alucard > Yoshino
Yuuki Mikan > Sakagami Tomoyo
Shiina > Ikkyuu Tensai
Koiwai Yotsuba > Alice Caroll

[Momo]

INVALID

My Yotsuba-chan ;-;

ResultsShow

1 Makise Kurisu - Kanbaru Suruga 3
1 Haqua Du Lot Herminium - Tedeza Rize 3
1 Yoshino - Rachel Alucard 1
0 Yuuki Mikan - Sakagami Tomoyo 4
0 Shiina - Ikkyuu Tensai 4
4 Koiwai Yotsuba - Alice Caroll 10

Makise Kurisu > Kanbaru Suruga - Confirm
Haqua Du Lot Herminium > Tedeza Rize - Confirm
Rachel Alucard > Yoshino
Yuuki Mikan > Sakagami Tomoyo
Shiina > Ikkyuu Tensai
Koiwai Yotsuba > Alice Caroll - Double

Match proposal:
Makise Kurisu > Kanbaru Suruga
Haqua Du Lot Herminium > Tedeza Rize
Yoshino > Rachel Alucard
Yuuki Mikan > Sakagami Tomoyo
Shiina > Ikkyuu Tensai
Koiwai Yotsuba > Alice Caroll

[mazza411]

INVALID

"My Yotsuba" indeed. Any other opponent and Alice would get my vote no question, but how can I vote against my daughteru?

ResultsShow

1 Makise Kurisu - Kanbaru Suruga 3
2 Haqua Du Lot Herminium - Tedeza Rize 3
1 Yoshino - Rachel Alucard 1
1 Yuuki Mikan - Sakagami Tomoyo 4
0 Shiina - Ikkyuu Tensai 4
6 Koiwai Yotsuba - Alice Caroll 10

Makise Kurisu > Kanbaru Suruga
Haqua Du Lot Herminium > Tedeza Rize - confirm
Yoshino > Rachel Alucard
Yuuki Mikan > Sakagami Tomoyo - confirm
Shiina > Ikkyuu Tensai
Koiwai Yotsuba > Alice Carroll - double

Match proposal:
Makise Kurisu > Kanbaru Suruga
Haqua Du Lot Herminium > Tedeza Rize
Rachel Alucard > Yoshino
Yuuki Mikan > Sakagami Tomoyo
Shiina > Ikkyuu Tensai
Koiwai Yotsuba > Alice Carroll

[Homura]

lischan's post only used one AP, which is invalid.

[lischan]

lischan's post only used one AP, which is invalid.

I saw that just then too I'm so sorry fixed now within the 15 minutes so it shouldn't affect anything.

[instrern2]

INVALID

So play on? Because finally a decent proposal and I need to sleep.

ResultsShow

2 Makise Kurisu - Kanbaru Suruga 3
3 Haqua Du Lot Herminium - Tedeza Rize 3
1 Yoshino - Rachel Alucard 1
1 Yuuki Mikan - Sakagami Tomoyo 4
0 Shiina - Ikkyuu Tensai 4
8 Koiwai Yotsuba - Alice Caroll 10

Makise Kurisu > Kanbaru Suruga - confirm
Haqua Du Lot Herminium > Tedeza Rize - confirm
Rachel Alucard > Yoshino
Yuuki Mikan > Sakagami Tomoyo
Shiina > Ikkyuu Tensai
Koiwai Yotsuba > Alice Carroll - double

Match proposal:
Makise Kurisu > Kanbaru Suruga
Haqua Du Lot Herminium > Tedeza Rize
Rachel Alucard > Yoshino
Sakagami Tomoyo > Yuuki Mikan
Shiina > Ikkyuu Tensai
Koiwai Yotsuba > Alice Carroll

[hinakatbklyn]

The minute Momo voted, the post should have been invalid making the other posts invalid..... but I bet the vote will be considered valid to make sure Alice loses.

And no, not sorry. Alice is the only one I have left.

[Chibasa]

Momo did you edit your vote (results parts) and Mazza's one after Lischan edit her vote?

I'm trying to understand what happened and in which order but it's pretty messy atm •m•

[Homura]

@hinakatbklyn

The Cause is losing, but the result is not settled yet. There is still time for you to fight some more for her, I mean if she is your only one left and you really want her to advance. It depends on you.

[hinakatbklyn]

Momo did you edit your vote (results parts) and Mazza's one after Lischan edit her vote?

I'm trying to understand what happened and in which order but it's pretty messy atm •m•

Can already see Momo's match proposal of Tensai/Shiina not having the disable when lischan edited.

And although my image is a link only rather than an image, I already went out for Alice more than any of my other favorites. Not much else I can do.

[Chibasa]

Momo did you edit your vote (results parts) and Mazza's one after Lischan edit her vote?

I'm trying to understand what happened and in which order but it's pretty messy atm •m•

Can already see Momo's match proposal of Tensai/Shiina not having the disable when lischan edited.

And although my image is a link only rather than an image, I already went out for Alice more than any of my other favorites. Not much else I can do.

But Momo and Mazza have good accounts in results and they voted before lischan edit. That's why I think it's a bit messy for now.

[hinakatbklyn]

Unfortunately, I missed the original vote before the edit. The only possibility I could think of is the points were added but not all the confirms and reverses were included but I can't prove it unless I saw the original post.

[Momo]

Sorry, I was in a consult. I didn't edit my vote or anyone else's posts. There was no strikethrough for Shiina/Ikkyuu Tensei's match when I posted so that would have been lischan's edit -- nothing else about the matches or results are different from when I saw it. I didn't notice if she only added the line, or if the disable wasn't there either originally; did Homura see it? But I would vote the same way regardless (regardless for lischan/instrern/lischan v2) and even if you shuffled around mazza, instrern and my matches, the change doesn't affect the matches we voted on so the results wouldn't change. And I guess it doesn't matter if she edited it within the 15 minute "okay to edit" grace period Chibasa set before?

Any edit that mazza could have made would be reflected in the forum and Desu can verify in the mod log that I didn't edit mazza's post, though now that I look at the log, Gara deleted 2 posts in this thread yesterday. I don't know the nature of the posts however

[Homura]

lischan's original post:

ResultsShow

0 Makise Kurisu - Kanbaru Suruga 3
0 Haqua Du Lot Herminium - Tedeza Rize 3
1 Yoshino - Rachel Alucard 1
0 Yuuki Mikan - Sakagami Tomoyo 4
0 Shiina - Ikkyuu Tensai 4
2 Koiwai Yotsuba - Alice Caroll 10

Kanbaru Suruga > Makise Kurisu
Tedeza Rize > Haqua Du Lot Herminium
Yoshino > Rachel Alucard (confirm)
Sakagami Tomoyo > Yuuki Mikan ( confirm)
Ikkyuu Tensai > Shiina
Alice Caroll > Koiwai Yotsuba (reverse)

Match proposal:
Makise Kurisu > Kanbaru Suruga
Haqua Du Lot Herminium > Tedeza Rize
Rachel Alucard > Yoshino
Yuuki Mikan > Sakagami Tomoyo
Shiina > Ikkyuu Tensai
Koiwai Yotsuba > Alice Caroll

Yeah, the only thing she added later is that disable, so it literally has no effect except causing Momo to miss that strikeout, which is a match Momo didn't do any action on.

[mazza411]

I also did not edit anything. I saw the change but I thought it didn't affect my post since it was fixed within 15min.

I suppose you can look at it either as lischan's post is not invalid and result is to use instrern's post, or lischan's post was invalid so Momo and my initial posts are as well, then lischan revotes, then instrern votes (unaffected as I had the same proposal as lischan) then Momo would have just before (unchanged again for the matches she used) and then me now, and I would again vote the same way. For simplicity's sake, in the second scenario I elect to change my proposal to instrern's one so next voter should use instrern's post.

I believe it should be clarified whether the 15 minutes "no BP" edit window applies if other people also post before the edit. I was under the impression that it applies regardless of other posts, so as long as it's edited within 15 minutes then it is valid +/- a repost of anything that needs to be adjusted.

[Kurobako]

I don't know if this means it's sorted or not, but mazza411's logic seems okay so even if it's lischan>Momo>mazza411>instrern2 or lischan>instrern2>Momo>mazza411[new post] and the only changes inbetween posts is the score calculation, this should be valid and it should be easier (especially if the alternative is a time extension):

INVALID

ResultsShow

3 Makise Kurisu - Kanbaru Suruga 3
4 Haqua Du Lot Herminium - Tedeza Rize 3
1 Yoshino - Rachel Alucard 1
1 Yuuki Mikan - Sakagami Tomoyo 4
0 Shiina - Ikkyuu Tensai 4
10 Koiwai Yotsuba - Alice Caroll 10

Makise Kurisu > Kanbaru Suruga [confirm]
Haqua Du Lot Herminium > Tedeza Rize [confirm]
Rachel Alucard > Yoshino
Sakagami Tomoyo > Yuuki Mikan
Shiina > Ikkyuu Tensai
Koiwai Yotsuba > Alice Carroll [double]

Match proposal:
Makise Kurisu > Kanbaru Suruga
Haqua Du Lot Herminium > Tedeza Rize
Yoshino > Rachel Alucard
Sakagami Tomoyo > Yuuki Mikan
Shiina > Ikkyuu Tensai
Koiwai Yotsuba > Alice Carroll

I guess I'm still averse to touching those matches just in case...

[oneoshron]

I think I might be confused about the rules now... I thought Chibasa-sensei said we could edit our votes indefinitely if no one voted, so if there is a 15-minute "window", wouldn't it be applied only if someone votes?

INVALID

ResultsShow

4 Makise Kurisu - Kanbaru Suruga 3
5 Haqua Du Lot Herminium - Tedeza Rize 3
1 Yoshino - Rachel Alucard 1
1 Yuuki Mikan - Sakagami Tomoyo 4
0 Shiina - Ikkyuu Tensai 4
12 Koiwai Yotsuba - Alice Caroll 10

Makise Kurisu > Kanbaru Suruga - (Confirm)
Haqua Du Lot Herminium > Tedeza Rize - (Confirm)
Yoshino > Rachel Alucard
Sakagami Tomoyo > Yuuki Mikan
Shiina > Ikkyuu Tensai
Koiwai Yotsuba > Alice Carroll - (Double)

Match proposal:
Makise Kurisu > Kanbaru Suruga
Haqua Du Lot Herminium > Tedeza Rize
Yoshino > Rachel Alucard
Sakagami Tomoyo > Yuuki Mikan
Shiina > Ikkyuu Tensai
Koiwai Yotsuba > Alice Carroll

me too... but those matches are the ones I support most so I would probably also vote the same way \( ^3^)/

[Chibasa]

lischan's post only used one AP, which is invalid.

I interpreted that lischan didn't used 2 free confirm and only one AP before the edit haha. It's all makes sense now. Woody, your bakaness is really contagious.

About the 15 minutes window I guess I'll have to read again 50 forum pages to find what we decided, I really don't remember what we exactly said.

[Exxin]

INVALID

I guess that means progressing is OK by WOG

ResultsShow

4 Makise Kurisu - Kanbaru Suruga 3
6 Haqua Du Lot Herminium - Tedeza Rize 3
2 Yoshino - Rachel Alucard 1
1 Yuuki Mikan - Sakagami Tomoyo 4
2 Shiina - Ikkyuu Tensai 4
12 Koiwai Yotsuba - Alice Caroll 10

Makise Kurisu > Kanbaru Suruga
Haqua Du Lot Herminium > Tedeza Rize {confirm}
Yoshino > Rachel Alucard {confirm}
Sakagami Tomoyo > Yuuki Mikan
Shiina > Ikkyuu Tensai {double}
Koiwai Yotsuba > Alice Carroll

Match proposal:
Makise Kurisu > Kanbaru Suruga
Haqua Du Lot Herminium > Tedeza Rize
Rachel Alucard > Yoshino
Yuuki Mikan > Sakagami Tomoyo
Shiina > Ikkyuu Tensai
Alice Carroll > Koiwai Yotsuba

[Asuna]

INVALID

ResultsShow

5 Makise Kurisu - Kanbaru Suruga 3
7 Haqua Du Lot Herminium - Tedeza Rize 3
2 Yoshino - Rachel Alucard 1
2 Yuuki Mikan - Sakagami Tomoyo 4
2 Shiina - Ikkyuu Tensai 4
12 Koiwai Yotsuba - Alice Caroll 10

Makise Kurisu > Kanbaru Suruga - confirm
Haqua Du Lot Herminium > Tedeza Rize - confirm
Rachel Alucard > Yoshino - disable
Yuuki Mikan > Sakagami Tomoyo - confirm
Shiina > Ikkyuu Tensai
Alice Carroll > Koiwai Yotsuba

Match proposal:
Kanbaru Suruga > Makise Kurisu
Haqua Du Lot Herminium > Tedeza Rize
Rachel Alucard > Yoshino
Yuuki Mikan > Sakagami Tomoyo
Shiina > Ikkyuu Tensai
Koiwai Yotsuba > Alice Carroll